Brooklyn Properties between $4,000,000 and $5,000,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for between $4,000,000 and $5,000,000 properties available in Brooklyn and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Brooklyn real estate market? Sign up for a Brooklyn Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Brooklyn Properties between $4,000,000 and $5,000,000 for Sale

$4,390,000

8 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1042058 MLS

01 Gut-renovated townhouse A redeveloped three-story walk-up taken to the studs and body envelope —mechanical systems, kitchens, baths, and facadesrebuilt. 02 Free-market income with embedded value-add upside Every unit is free-market, with full exposure to rent growth and no rent-regulation overhang. Additional upside with duplex garden unit buildout and mark to market lease-up. 03 R6 zoning A moderate-density district permitting as-of-right expansion, rare among Williamsburg's low-rise, three-family townhouse stock. 04 Transit at the corner The L/G at Lorimer Street and Metropolitan Avenue is roughly 0.1 miles away —Transit Score 96, Walk Score 99. 05 At the epicenter of NYC’s most sought-after live/work/play neighborhood North Williamsburg - world-class restaurants, celebrated cocktail bars, waterfront parks, and a thriving creative economy that continues to set the standard for urban living. 06 A lean carry $6,397 in annual real estate taxes under holds operating cost well below the borough norm.

427 Metropolitan Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,800,000

1027619 MLS

Introducing a rare and distinguished commercial opportunity in the heart of Sunset Park. Situated on the prominent corner of 2nd Avenue and 43rd Street, this property commands attention with exceptional visibility, wide street frontage, and a strong architectural presence. The freestanding two-story masonry building offers approximately 2,760 sq ft of versatile space, ideal for office, retail, creative, or flex industrial uses. A defining feature of this asset is the expansive open lot, providing a large parking area and generous outdoor operations space. Well-suited for truck staging, fleet parking, loading, equipment placement, or future expansion—this feature is increasingly rare in the Sunset Park industrial corridor and significantly elevates both operational flexibility and long-term redevelopment potential. Set on an impressive 8,014 sq ft corner parcel with wide, clean dimensions of 100.17 ft × 80 ft, the property lies within M1-2 zoning, allowing up to 16,028 buildable sq ft. Large, high-exposure corner sites with such substantial buildable potential are exceptionally limited in this rapidly evolving district. The site supports an array of premium development concepts, including modern flex industrial, a creative office campus, showroom with warehouse, boutique self-storage, production or content studios, or a flagship logistics center. The combination of corner exposure, broad lot dimensions, and a large outdoor yard enhances design opportunities and accommodates both small- and large-scale visions. Its superb location—just minutes from Industry City, the Brooklyn Army Terminal, and the BQE—makes it highly advantageous for businesses requiring strong transportation connectivity. Demand for high-quality commercial and industrial space in this corridor continues to grow. This property represents a rare chance to secure a substantial corner lot with exceptional flexibility, major upside potential, and enduring value for developers, investors, and owner-users.

4223 2nd Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,650,000

1009859 MLS

16 & 18 Lenox Road Unit #12, Brooklyn

$4,990,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1008172 MLS

A rare opportunity to own a brand-new luxury residence in the heart of Brooklyn’s Ditmas Park / Prospect Park South neighborhood. This stunning home features an expansive first floor with a large living room, open-concept kitchen, energy-efficient appliances, and central heating and cooling.The main level includes 2 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom. The second floor offers 3 private suites, each with its own walk-in closet. The third floor features a grand primary suite with an oversized walk-in dressing room.The home also includes a private double garage—extremely rare in Brooklyn—and a basement with a separate entrance

353 E 17th Street, Brooklyn

$4,500,000

8 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 995921 MLS

Prime Bedford-Stuyvesant 2-family opportunity with serious income-producing potential and long-term upside. Welcome to 28 Saint Andrews Place, a brick 4-story, 3-family property offering a spacious layout with 8 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, 2 half bathrooms, duplex-style living, and a finished basement for added flexibility. This property is ideal for an end-user looking to live and collect income, or an investor seeking a solid Brooklyn asset in a high-demand rental corridor. The building offers generous interior space, multiple levels of use, and strong upside for repositioning, rental growth, or long-term hold value. Conveniently located near major transportation options, including nearby A/C subway access, LIRR Nostrand Avenue, and multiple Brooklyn bus routes. The surrounding area offers access to Fulton Street and Nostrand Avenue retail corridors, neighborhood shopping, restaurants, schools, parks, and everyday conveniences.

28 Saint Andrews Place, Brooklyn

$4,000,000

987785 MLS

A prime commercial opportunity in the heart of Brooklyn. This versatile property is currently configured as an event venue and offers multiple levels of usable space, making it ideal for investors or business owners seeking a turnkey or adaptable commercial asset. The property features two full floors plus a basement, allowing for flexible use such as event hosting, lounge, retail, office, or mixed-use operations. Each level provides open space potential, with the layout supporting high-capacity gatherings and multiple revenue streams. Located on a highly trafficked corridor, the property benefits from strong visibility, steady foot traffic, and convenient access to public transportation, making it an excellent location for continued venue use or redevelopment. This is a rare opportunity to acquire a well-positioned commercial property in a growing Brooklyn market.

2265 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,607,000

982586 MLS

Rare opportunity to add the largest mixed-use property currently available in the 11236 zip code to your portfolio. A newly constructed (2024) elevator building featuring 12 residential units, ground-floor retail occupied by a pawn shop, 8 enclosed parking spaces, and a 35-year 421-a tax exemption. This 4-story building is home to 8 free-market units and 4 affordable units, along with 2,223SF of retail space, private parking, laundry, and accessory and bicycle storage. The residential rent roll is strong at $31,122/month ($373,464/year). There are 8 parking spaces that can rent for $150/space ($14,400/year). Owner pays electric (approximately $600/month for common areas and the elevator) and water ($16,746.78 for 2025). This property offers a rare combination of new construction, multiple income streams, and long-term tax advantages in Brooklyn.

8623 Flatlands Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,700,000

972113 MLS

137 Wyckoff Avenue is a mixed-use investment property located in the heart of Bushwick. The building consists of seven residential units above one ground-floor retail space. The residential component includes three rent-stabilized units and four free-market units. Current rents are below market, presenting a clear value-add opportunity through future rent growth and improved management. The retail space is occupied by Dunkin' under a long-term lease, providing stable and reliable income. The property offers investors a balanced income stream with a strong commercial tenant and meaningful upside potential in one of Brooklyn’s fastest-growing neighborhoods.

137 Wyckoff Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,100,000

969749 MLS

Prime Greenpoint 6-Family Investment Opportunity. This fully renovated building offers modern, high-end finishes and strong in-place income in one of Brooklyn’s most desirable rental markets. Each apartment features spacious layouts, queen-sized bedrooms, stainless steel kitchens, in-unit washer/dryers, each room Seprete heat & A/C, hardwood floors, and high ceilings. Units include two stylish bathrooms with contemporary tile work, including a standing shower and deep soaking tub, while primary bedrooms feature en-suite baths and generous closet space. The property is fully occupied and free-market, providing excellent cash flow with long-term upside. Located in the heart of vibrant Greenpoint, moments from popular restaurants, cafes, parks, boutique shopping, and convenient transportation. A rare opportunity to acquire a turnkey, income-producing asset in one of Brooklyn’s most sought-after neighborhoods.

42 Driggs Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 968159 MLS

Renovated Two Family Mixed-Use Building With Storefront In Ocean Hill For Sale! Building Sitting On A Lot Size 25X31.83. Building Size 25X31.83, Total Of 1,591 Sf. Great Layout Of Two 1Br Apt Over Store. Total Of 1682 Sqft. With a Potential of An Buildable 1,682 Sqft. Layout Of 2BR/1BA Apartment And 1BR/1BA Apartment On The Upper Level. Retail Store Located on the First Level With Access To The Basement. Great Rental Investment Income. Just A Short Distance To Broadway Junction, Which Has The L, A, & J Trains & Building Size 25x32 Total. All info deemed reliable but not guaranteed and must be reverified. Units.

2446 Dean Street, Brooklyn

$4,499,000

953529 MLS

Welcome to an exceptional development opportunity in one of Brooklyn’s most dynamic and rapidly evolving residential corridors. 2183 & 2187 Bergen Street, Brooklyn, NY 11233 present a rare chance to acquire two contiguous lots totaling approximately 7,295 sq ft, ideally positioned in the heart of Bedford-Stuyvesant, bordering Crown Heights and Ocean Hill. This prime assemblage offers a compelling canvas for developers and builders seeking to capitalize on strong residential demand in a high-growth area. The lots feature approximate dimensions of 25 ft x 101.08 ft and 40 ft x 107.17 ft, providing excellent frontage and depth for efficient building design. The property is located within an R7A / R6 / C2-4 zoning district, allowing for a wide range of residential and mixed-use development possibilities. Zoning & Development Highlights: * Housing Program Eligible? MIH & UAP Housing Program, residential development in an R7A district may achieve a maximum FAR of up to 5.01, subject to compliance with program requirements. * Substantial Buildable Area?With an allowable FAR increase, the site offers up to approximately 36,000 buildable square feet, presenting significant upside for a well-designed residential or mixed-use project. * Flexible Development Scenarios & Potential uses include: * Multi-unit residential building * Mixed-use development with commercial ground floor and residential above * Community facility use * A combination of the above, subject to zoning and approvals. Strategic Location: Situated in a neighborhood actively encouraging thoughtful development, this property benefits from strong community infrastructure, increasing demand for quality housing, and excellent proximity to transportation, retail, and neighborhood amenities. The R7A zoning promotes contextual, high-quality residential buildings that integrate seamlessly into the surrounding streetscape while supporting long-term neighborhood growth. This is a rare opportunity to develop a meaningful residential project in one of Brooklyn’s most sought-after and opportunity-rich zoning districts. No offer shall be considered accepted until contracts of sale are fully executed by all parties. All information, including but not limited to lot size, zoning, taxes, and development potential, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

2187 Bergen Street, Brooklyn

$4,999,000

927715 MLS

Introducing a prime development opportunity at 2383 Stillwell Ave, situated in the thriving Gravesend neighborhood of Brooklyn. This expansive corner lot offers a generous 19,200 square feet of potential, making it an ideal investment for developers and builders seeking to capitalize on one of Brooklyn's most promising areas.

2383 Stillwell Avenue, Brooklyn

$4,350,000

913618 MLS

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! 2,500 Sqft. Development Site In Bed-Stuy Near I-278 For Sale!!! The Property Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, V-1/M1-1 Zoning, Low Property Taxes, Fenced Lot, +++!!! The Property Is Located In The Heart Of Bed-Stuy In Between Myrtle Avenue & Park Avenue!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, Chase Bank, The Home Depot, FedEx, Verizon, Dunkin’, Subway, Carvel Express, Duane Reade, Family Dollar, KFC, +++!!! This Property Has HUGE Upside Potential!!! This Could Be Your Next Development Site / Home For Your Business!!! Expenses: Taxes: $6,874 Ann. Total Expenses: $6,874 Ann.

102 Walworth Street, Brooklyn

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.